Comments on: Pink Floyd – Riding The Cow (Godfather Records GR515/516/517)

By: eric99

eric99 — Thu, 01 Jul 2010 11:18:59 +0000

…or show a little gratitude that someone who gives so much of their time to go above and beyond for a hobby they love. A lot of these reviews are highly researched and well thought out. That all takes time. Believe me.

By: dimip

dimip — Thu, 01 Jul 2010 09:58:52 +0000

@Roberto : Looks like you had to PAY for somebody’s hours of work in order to give HIS point of view on something, to actually HELP other who are interested in it ….
This site is not Amazon and CMR doesn’t sell the titles it deals with, nor does it profits from the bootleg label’s sales (at least I reckon).
It would be nice if people reading reviews on this site would just be grateful to find them, or simply shut up if they aren’t… too much complaining moans in the commentaries this time, I wonder how it can be motivating for the reviewers giving time and money to keep it all going…

By: gsparaco

gsparaco — Wed, 30 Jun 2010 17:23:17 +0000

I guess I don’t understand how my review is not “appropriate and honest.” The sound quality is good for both. And I stated that both shows are quite rare. However, I do think Godfather should have spliced the missing song from the second San Francisco tape to complete the show. So I thought Godfather dropped the ball on this one.

If I praise Godfather releases, then I’m accused of being their saleman. If I criticize a Godfather release, then I’m being dishonest. Tells me I’m doing something right…

By: ROBERTO

ROBERTO — Wed, 30 Jun 2010 16:32:13 +0000

it’s been a long time since i left a comment on pf items on your site, that’s because i found the latest reviews on the ” GODFATHER ” items quite right and honest, i don’t read anymore your reviews on the sigma items because after ” santa monica 71″, “deep space”, and “maryland73 ” ( that i bought hoping to have value for money) i confirm my thought that these japanese guys have always the best treatment even if they offer weak releases ( “santa maonca 71″ is really horrible…), so i believe as a, long-time floyd collector, that you should review only led zep stuff and let the floyd items to someone else… i purchased this title at the Milan cds and records fair and , leaving apart the fantastic packaging( great booklet with nice notes and rare pictures, especially of the fillmore programme) , this item provides one of the most interesting floyd releases of the year 2010, two top gigs ( and the fillmore one is damn rare) and with a great sound too, i listened to the tape sometimes ago and compared to the final release there’s a great effort in mastering, any word on your review about this? any word on your review about the esssy we can find inside the packaging and in the booklet too? any word about the effort of offering this stuff at a reasonable price? no, that’s why i firmly believe that this review is really not appropriate and honest, sorry to say but that’s it..